Self-control is the ability to inhibit impulses, while self-regulation concerns how the brain and body respond to stress and restore balance. The capacity for self-control depends on sufficient regulation and energy.
Self-control is the capacity to inhibit an impulse or override an immediate response. Self-regulation, in its original psychophysiological sense, concerns how the brain and body respond to stress, expend energy, and recover from that expenditure. The two are related but fundamentally different. When stress load is high and energy is depleted, the brain systems required for effortful self-control may be less available. Self-Reg shifts the question from “How do we get more self-control?” to “What is affecting this person’s capacity for self-control right now?” Reducing excessive stress and supporting restoration can make self-control more available and, in some situations, make so much effortful control unnecessary.
We often ask people to “use self-control” precisely when their capacity for self-control is lowest. Think about how much harder patience becomes when you are exhausted, hungry, rushed, frightened, or overwhelmed. The same is true for waiting, inhibiting an impulse, concentrating, or choosing words carefully.
If we interpret every failure of self-control as unwillingness, we may respond by demanding even more effort. Self-Reg prompts another question: What is making self-control so difficult right now?
Reducing excessive stress and restoring energy can make self-control more available and, sometimes, reduce the amount of effortful self-control needed in the first place.
Self-control depends on regulation; when stress is high, effort alone may not be enough.
Hear Stuart explain why the answer to this question is: no. And how that difference matters and is helpful!
Explore stress, energy, regulation, and the changing capacity for self-control through your own experience.
Explore Stuart’s deeper rethinking of self-control, self-regulation, stress, and behaviour.